The best option that describes what must have happened in the past in an area with a large petroleum trap is:
B. Organic matter must have been buried and placed under intense heat and pressure until it became petroleum. Then, the petroleum must have collected inside an impermeable underground rock formation.
This option accurately reflects the process of petroleum formation, which typically involves the burial of organic material, its transformation under heat and pressure over millions of years, and subsequent trapping in impermeable rock formations that prevent the petroleum from migrating further.