Based on the observations provided, the correct conclusion is:
Only species Y is anaerobic.
Here's the reasoning:
- Species X producing CO2 and H2O during cellular respiration indicates it is undergoing aerobic respiration, where oxygen is used, and the byproducts are carbon dioxide and water.
- Species Y, producing ethyl alcohol and CO2, suggests it is undergoing alcoholic fermentation, which is a type of anaerobic process (it does not use oxygen).
Therefore, species Y is the one that is anaerobic, while species X is aerobic.