Now that you have watched the film El Norte (USA, 1983) and written a paper on it, answer ONE of the following questions. Remember that you must reply and comment to at least one classmate to receive full credit for the discussions.

1.Some question the motives or reasons why people immigrate in general and why people want to immigrate to the US. Do you think the director effectively details the reasons why Rosa and Enrique leave their country? Did this movie affect your perception of immigration and how immigrants live in this country?

1 answer

In "El Norte," director Gregory Nava effectively highlights the multifaceted reasons behind the immigration of Rosa and Enrique. The film portrays the socio-political turmoil in Guatemala, illustrating how oppressive regimes, violence, and poverty force individuals to seek safety and better opportunities elsewhere. The narrative deeply humanizes the characters, showcasing their struggles, dreams, and resilience, which adds layers to their motivation for leaving.

Through Rosa and Enrique's experiences, the film underscores the harsh realities of life in their homeland and the lengths to which they go for a chance at a better future. Their journey to the United States is not just a search for economic opportunity; it is also about escaping persecution and the desire for a life with dignity. The film's portrayal of the dangers they face while crossing the border and the challenges they encounter once in the U.S. further emphasizes that immigration is rarely a straightforward or easy path.

Watching "El Norte" did change my perspective on immigration. It reminded me that immigrants are not just statistics or faceless individuals but are people with stories, hopes, and fears. The film highlights the cultural richness that immigrants bring to a new country but also the sacrifices and struggles they endure. Overall, it fosters a deeper empathy for their circumstances and the systemic issues that drive people to leave their homes.

What about you? How did the film resonate with your understanding of immigration?