Colleen made her first mistake in the step where she rewrote the fraction One-half.
The correct way to rewrite One-half using a common denominator of 8 is to multiply both the numerator and denominator by 4, resulting in \( \frac{4}{8} \).
So the correct answer is: The fraction One-half should have been rewritten as StartFraction 4 Over 8 EndFraction.