Question
Statement 1: For many new immigrants, arriving at Ellis Island was a hopeful but anxious experience.
Statement 2: Ellis Island is a place rich with history that everyone should visit at least once.
Why is the first statement a better example of a thesis statement than the second statement?
(1 point)
Responses
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement includes a transition.
Statement 2: Ellis Island is a place rich with history that everyone should visit at least once.
Why is the first statement a better example of a thesis statement than the second statement?
(1 point)
Responses
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement includes a transition.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
The best response is:
**The first statement summarizes a central idea.**
This is because a thesis statement asserts a specific perspective or central idea that the writer will support or explore in their writing. The first statement captures the complex emotions of immigrants arriving at Ellis Island and suggests a deeper exploration, making it a stronger thesis. The second statement is more opinion-based and does not summarize an idea that can be elaborated upon in an essay.
**The first statement summarizes a central idea.**
This is because a thesis statement asserts a specific perspective or central idea that the writer will support or explore in their writing. The first statement captures the complex emotions of immigrants arriving at Ellis Island and suggests a deeper exploration, making it a stronger thesis. The second statement is more opinion-based and does not summarize an idea that can be elaborated upon in an essay.