Yes, I'm confident in my response. Physical weathering involves the mechanical breakdown of rocks into smaller pieces without changing their chemical composition. The most relevant activity from your list is the one where the cookies are placed in a box and then shaken, as it represents the mechanical forces that can break rock apart through abrasion and impact.
Here’s a brief overview of why the other options are not suitable for modeling physical weathering:
-
Place a paper boat in a ditch, and then use water from a hose to make it sail away: This primarily demonstrates water flow and erosion rather than the physical breakdown of rock.
-
Place drops of acid on chalk, and then observe the chemical reaction: This represents chemical weathering because the acid reacts with the chalk, altering its chemical composition.
-
Place ice cream in a bowl, and then watch it melt: This does not model weathering; melting is a physical process related to temperature changes rather than mechanical breakdown like weathering.
So the shaking of cookies does best simulate the mechanical aspects of physical weathering. If you have further questions or discussions, feel free to share!