How does the total kinetic energy of a cannon and cannonball system change as the mass of the cannon increases and the energy of the blast remain the same?

1 answer

In a cannon and cannonball system, the total kinetic energy is a result of the energy imparted to the cannonball during the firing process, as well as the recoil experienced by the cannon due to the conservational dynamics of momentum.

  1. Conservation of Momentum: When the cannon is fired, it experiences a recoil in the opposite direction of the cannonball. The conservation of momentum states that the momentum before firing must equal the momentum after. Before firing, both the cannon and cannonball are at rest, so their total initial momentum is zero. After firing, we have:

\[ m_b \cdot v_b + m_c \cdot v_c = 0 \]

where:

  • \(m_b\) is the mass of the cannonball,
  • \(v_b\) is the velocity of the cannonball,
  • \(m_c\) is the mass of the cannon,
  • \(v_c\) is the recoil velocity of the cannon.

From this, we can express \(v_c\):

\[ v_c = -\frac{m_b \cdot v_b}{m_c} \]

  1. Total Kinetic Energy: The total kinetic energy (TKE) of the system after firing is given by:

\[ TKE = \frac{1}{2} m_b v_b^2 + \frac{1}{2} m_c v_c^2 \]

Substituting for \(v_c\) gives:

\[ TKE = \frac{1}{2} m_b v_b^2 + \frac{1}{2} m_c \left(-\frac{m_b \cdot v_b}{m_c}\right)^2 \]

This simplifies to:

\[ TKE = \frac{1}{2} m_b v_b^2 + \frac{1}{2} m_c \cdot \frac{m_b^2 \cdot v_b^2}{m_c^2} \]

\[ TKE = \frac{1}{2} m_b v_b^2 + \frac{1}{2} \frac{m_b^2 \cdot v_b^2}{m_c} \]

  1. Effects of Increasing Cannon Mass: If we keep the energy of the blast (which is responsible for the cannonball's initial velocity) constant while increasing the mass of the cannon, the cannon's recoil velocity decreases because of the increased denominator in the rebound velocity equation.

As a result, the total kinetic energy can be viewed in the context of energy conservation: the total energy input from the explosion remains constant, but as the cannon mass increases, a smaller fraction of that energy contributes to the kinetic energy of the cannon (since it moves slower). The kinetic energy of the cannonball will still depend on the same energy input, assuming the effective blast energy acts on mass \(m_b\) remains constant, and hence \(v_b\) will achieve some velocity defined by this blast energy.

In conclusion, as the mass of the cannon increases while keeping the energy of the blast constant, the cannonball will maintain a significant proportion of the energy, moving at a higher velocity compared to when the cannon was lighter, but the cannon will have much less kinetic energy due to its reduced recoil velocity. Therefore, the total kinetic energy of the system can change minimally if the cannonball velocity stays effectively constant, but the partitioning between the cannonball and cannon will change significantly.

The overall behavior indicates a higher mass cannon will translate more of the blast energy into kinetic energy of the cannonball compared to a lighter cannon. Thus, the distribution of kinetic energy between the cannon and the cannonball will depend on their respective masses and the context of how the blast energy imparts their velocities.