Henry David history of the Haymarket Affair 1936; repr. 1964 cause and effect

1 answer

The Haymarket Affair, also known as the Haymarket Riot, was a pivotal event in labor history that took place in Chicago on May 4, 1886. The incident stemmed from a labor movement advocating for an eight-hour workday and broader workers' rights. Below is a summary of the cause-and-effect elements of the Haymarket Affair based on its historical context:

Causes

  1. Labor Movement and Strikes: In the years leading up to the Haymarket Affair, there was a growing labor movement in the United States, with workers increasingly demanding better wages, shorter hours, and safer working conditions.

  2. The eight-hour workday: The push for an eight-hour workday became a major rallying cry during this period. Many labor organizations, including the Knights of Labor and the American Federation of Labor, actively promoted this goal.

  3. McCormick Reaper Works Strike: Just days before the Haymarket rally, workers at the McCormick Reaper Works went on strike. Police intervened, leading to violence and the deaths of several strikers, further inflaming tensions.

  4. Radicalism and Anarchism: Some labor activists, influenced by anarchist ideas, called for direct action and supported the use of revolutionary tactics. This radical element of the labor movement contributed to the atmosphere of unrest.

  5. Social and Economic Inequality: The rapid industrialization of the U.S. was accompanied by significant social and economic disparities, leading to widespread discontent among the working class.

The Event

  • On May 4, 1886, a peaceful protest meeting was held at Haymarket Square to rally support for the eight-hour workday and to protest against police violence. The meeting was attended by labor leaders, anarchists, and sympathizers.

  • As the protest was concluding, police attempted to disperse the crowd. Someone threw a bomb at the police, killing an officer and wounding several others, sparking chaos and violence. In the ensuing confrontation, multiple people on both sides were killed or injured.

Effects

  1. Public Backlash: The bombing and subsequent violence led to a public outcry against labor activists, particularly anarchists. Media portrayed the protest as a violent uprising, fueling anti-labor sentiment.

  2. Arrests and Trials: In the aftermath, police conducted sweeping arrests. Eight anarchist leaders were charged with conspiracy, leading to a highly publicized trial that garnered national attention. The trial was marked by prejudice against the defendants, and despite a lack of direct evidence linking them to the bombing, seven were convicted and sentenced to death.

  3. Execution and Legacy: In 1887, four of the anarchists were executed, one committed suicide, and two had their sentences commuted. The case highlighted issues of justice and fairness in the legal system, especially towards political radicals.

  4. Labor Movement Impacts: The Haymarket Affair had a lasting impact on the labor movement. While it initially led to a setback, it also galvanized the movement and served as a rallying point for future labor rights activism. The incident is commemorated by some labor groups as a symbol of the struggle for workers' rights.

  5. May Day: The Haymarket Affair is often linked to the establishment of International Workers' Day (May Day) on May 1st, celebrated as a day of labor solidarity and remembrance of the Haymarket martyrs.

In summary, the Haymarket Affair was a culmination of social unrest due to labor demands and radical influences, leading to violent confrontations, a controversial legal aftermath, and significant consequences for the labor movement in the United States.