The correct response to the student's claim is:
No, dominant traits in general tend to be less common in the population and continue to persist only because they are dominant over more common recessive alleles.
This is true because the prevalence of a trait in a population (how common it is) is influenced by factors such as natural selection, genetic drift, and mutation, not merely by whether a trait is dominant or recessive. A dominant trait can be less common than a recessive trait if the recessive trait has some advantage in certain environments or if it has been historically more prevalent in the population for any reason.