For this quarter’s independent reading project you will be assuming the role of a notable book critic whose opinions are widely revered by the masses for providing an honest overview of the books they have read. Your job will be to inform your audience of your own detailed opinions regarding the independent reading book you’ve chosen for quarter one. More details and the rubric on which your critical review will be graded on are below.

Instructions:
Your critical book review will be drafted in an essay-style format, but can be broken down by categories of review (ex: character development, plot, theme, setting). For each category, you will be providing your own honest, detailed opinions as to how good or bad you believe your book to be, and why. A brief intro paragraph introducing the book should be included as well as the beginning of your critical review. An example intro is below from Into the Wild.

Ex: Intro (recommendation example):

For this critical review I have chosen to examine Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer. The story revolves around a young man, who, in the early 1990’s, set about traveling around the United States in hopes to find enlightenment. While I enjoyed the reading thoroughly, I believe the greatest value it offers to readers is a more thorough examination of Christopher McCandless and his motivations for why he did what he did.While many individuals, including many Alaskans have argued he was ill-prepared and foolish, Jon Krakauer reveals that there is more to the story than what was originally painted by his own Outdoor magazine article. Overall, I would deem this book to be a must read for any individuals who sympathize with a sense of adventure and discovery, as well as individuals who have ever found themselves lured by thoughts of the great American wilderness, particularly in the Yukon regions of Alaska.

Alternative Intro (dissuasion example):

For this critical review I have chosen to examine Into the Wild by Jon Krakauer. The story revolves around a young man, who, in the early 1990’s, set about traveling around the United States in hopes to find enlightenment. While I enjoyed the reading thoroughly, I did take issue with ___________________, _______________, that I thought the story could have done without, as they tended to pull my attention away from the narrative at times. Regardless, this book definitely boasts of an impressive adventure, that while although we as readers may find difficult to understand or sympathize with, I believe for the most part can respect the raw effort made by one young man to fulfill a dream. Overall, while the book certainly advertises an appeal for individuals who may consider themselves adventurous and outdoorsy, the self-admitted bias by Krakauer I believe unfortunately compromises the integrity of the story and places Chris too highly on a pedestal of worship. Thus, my overall recommendation would be that if you’re looking for a good non-fiction adventure story, you’re better off looking elsewhere.

A Note on Your Works Cited Page:
For this report, you will need to cite where you found your information regarding the author, as well as your book. Consult the following formulas for both book and website publication below:
Book: Last Name, First Name. Title of Book. Publisher, Publication Date.
Website: Last Name, First Name. “Title of Website”. Title of Container. Publisher, Publication Date. URL. Access Date.
Feel free to consult the opening to this sample report to give you an idea on how to format your own report:

Rubric:
Criteria List
Exceptional 10
Proficient 9
Marginal 7.5
Insufficient 5
Author Information
Author info is highly detailed and clearly enhances audience’s overall understanding of the book.
Author info is detailed and enhance’s audience’s overall understanding of the book.
Author info is lacking in detail and does not provides minimal benefit to audience’s understanding of the book.
Author info is greatly lacking or missing altogether. Does not offer any benefit or may confuse audience’s understanding of book.

Book Premise
Premise is highly detailed and organized allowing the audience to gain an ample understanding of what they can expect when reading the book
Premise is detailed and organized allowing audience to have an understanding of what they can expect when reading the book.
Premise is lacking in both detail and organization. Audience has difficulty understanding what they can expect when reading the book.
Premise is haphazardly organized and detailed. Audience is left confused and wanting for further explanation.
Theme (fiction and certain non-fiction like biographies, autobiographies, and memoirs)

Main-Idea (non-fiction such as academic texts, historical accounts, self-help or how-to)
At least two themes/main ideas are explored. An Ample explanation is provided for how each theme/main idea is present, and its overall importance of to the book. More than two pieces of text evidence present.
At least one theme/main idea is explored. Suitable explanation is provided for how the theme/main idea is present, and its overall importance to the book. At least two pieces of text evidence present.
At least one theme/ main idea is explored. Explanation as to how the theme/main idea is present may be lacking or is confusing. At least one piece of text evidence present.
Information on themes/main ideas present in book is missing altogether. Information on themes/main ideas is not present or confusing to the point of hindering audience understanding. Evidence missing.
Favorite or Least Favorite Character(fiction, and certain non-fiction such as biographies, autobiographies, and memoirs)
Ample description is provided for a main character, as well as a thorough analysis on why they’re your favorite or least favorite. More than two pieces of evidence present.
Suitable description is provided for a main character, as well as detailed analysis to why they’re your favorite or least favorite. At least two pieces of evidence present.
Questionable description is provided for a main character. Limited analysis is available on why they’re your favorite or least favorite. At least one piece of evidence present.
Minimal or no description is provided for a main character. Analysis on why they’re your favorite or least favorite is missing or difficult to understand.
Info Usefulness and Relevance.
(Non-fiction such as academic texts, historical accounts, self-help or how-to)
Student provides a thorough summary of how the information provided in their book helped or did not help them. Student provides at least two detailed avenues of thought as to how the information is relevant to their own lives, or to which target audience it could be relevant to, and why.
Student provides suitable summary of how the information provided in their book helped or did not help them. Student provides at least two clear avenues of thought as to how the information is relevant to their own lives, or to which target audience it could be relevant to, and why.
Student provides questionable summary of how the information provided in their book helped or did not help them. Student provides at least one avenue of thought as to how the information is relevant to their own lives, or to which target audience it could be relevant to, and why.
Summary of information and relevance to student’s life may be missing or too confusing to understand. Information provided hinders audience’s understanding of the book.
Critic’s Final Conclusions
Student provides a descriptive synopsis of their book and final recommendation or dissuasion to whether others should read it or not, and why.
Student provides a suitable synopsis of their book and final recommendation or dissuasion to whether others should read it or not, and why.
Student provides a minimal/questionable synopsis of their book and final recommendation or dissuasion to whether others should read it or not, and why.
Student does not provide synopsis of their book and final recommendation or dissuasion to whether others should read it or not, and why.
Grammar/Formatting/Spelling
Critique is formatted in MLA style. There are little to no errors in grammar and spelling.
Critique is formatted in MLA style. There are some errors in grammar and spelling, but they do not detract from the overall critique.
Parts of the critique make be formatted in MLA style. There are many errors in grammar and spelling that detract from the overall critique.
Critique is not formatted in MLA style. Errors in grammar and spelling may be too numerous to count, severely hindering the overall critique.

Total: /60

base it off the book the outsiders

1 answer

Critical Book Review of The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton

For this critical review, I have chosen to examine The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton. This classic novel, first published in 1967, tells the story of Ponyboy Curtis, a young member of the Greasers, a group of working-class teenagers who are frequently at odds with the wealthier Socs. Through Ponyboy's eyes, Hinton explores themes of class struggle, brotherhood, and the complexities of adolescence in a divided society. I found The Outsiders to be an insightful and compelling read, capturing the essence of youth in the face of societal pressures while illustrating the emotional landscapes of its characters. Ultimately, I would recommend this book to anyone interested in understanding the intricacies of growing up amid conflict and the search for identity.

Author Information

S.E. Hinton, born in Tulsa, Oklahoma, in 1948, wrote The Outsiders when she was just 16 years old. The novel has since been hailed as a groundbreaking work that gave voice to the teenage experience in a raw and relatable way. Hinton's own experiences as a teenager growing up in the socio-economically divided neighborhoods of Tulsa heavily influenced her writing. Her ability to convey the struggles of adolescence while engaging readers with authentic dialogue and relatable characters is part of what makes her work stand out. This depth of understanding is essential for appreciating The Outsiders, as it offers a nuanced view of the conflicts between social classes, family dynamics, and the quest for belonging.

Book Premise

The premise of The Outsiders revolves around the dichotomy between the Greasers and the Socs, presenting a vivid depiction of teen life marked by class conflict. The narrative follows Ponyboy Curtis and his close-knit group of friends as they navigate their tumultuous lives amidst violence, loyalty, and loss. As the story unfolds, we witness the deep bonds of brotherhood among the Greasers, especially between Ponyboy and his brothers, Darry and Sodapop. The book expertly highlights the challenges each character faces, including the pressures exerted by their social status, family expectations, and personal aspirations. Hinton's deft storytelling allows readers to understand the motivations behind the characters' actions, making the social commentary on class struggle feel both relevant and impactful.

Themes

The Outsiders explores several crucial themes, two of which stand out prominently: class struggle and the search for identity. The disparity between the Greasers and the Socs serves as the backbone of the narrative, exemplifying how socioeconomic factors shape individual experiences. Hinton illustrates the harsh realities of life for the Greasers, who endure constant judgment and brutality from their more affluent counterparts. This theme speaks to a broader audience, prompting readers to reflect on the social divisions that continue to exist in society today.

The second theme, the search for identity, is masterfully portrayed through Ponyboy's journey throughout the novel. As he grapples with his place within the Greaser community and the expectations of those around him, he ultimately seeks to define himself beyond the stigma attached to his social class. Key moments, such as his conversations with Johnny and his relationship with Cherry Valance, reveal the internal struggles that many adolescents face in trying to carve out their own identities amid external pressures. This theme resonates deeply with readers of all ages, encouraging introspection and empathy.

Favorite Character

My favorite character in The Outsiders is Johnny Cade, a sensitive and troubled member of the Greasers. Johnny's character is compelling due to his vulnerability and tragic circumstances. He comes from an abusive household and often feels like an outcast, but his compassionate nature shines through in moments of crisis. For instance, when he and Ponyboy find themselves in peril after defending Dally, Johnny's courage emerges, leading to his significant decision to save the children from the burning church. This act of heroism illustrates his ultimate desire to make a difference in the world, reflecting a depth of character that endears him to the reader. Johnny's struggles and growth throughout the novel are a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, making him a standout character that many can relate to.

Info Usefulness and Relevance

The insights I gained from The Outsiders are invaluable, particularly regarding issues of class and identity. Hinton's vivid portrayal of teenage struggles provides a useful lens for understanding the dynamics of social conflict and the importance of empathy. The book encourages readers to challenge their own perceptions of others based on superficial classifications such as social class or appearance. As a student myself, I find the themes relevant not only to my own life but to societal issues that persist in today’s world. It instills a sense of responsibility to remain open-minded and understanding toward others, regardless of their background, reminding us all of our shared humanity.

Critic’s Final Conclusions

In conclusion, The Outsiders by S.E. Hinton is a timeless exploration of teenage life that deftly addresses themes of class struggle and identity. Through rich character development and an engaging narrative, Hinton invites readers to contemplate the complexities of social divisions and the universal search for belonging. I highly recommend this novel to others, especially those looking for a poignant tale that delves into the intricacies of adolescence and the human experience. Its lessons resonate deeply, making it not just a story about the Greasers and the Socs, but about all of us navigating a world often divided by lines of our own making.

Works Cited

Hinton, S.E. The Outsiders. Viking Press, 1967.

Similar Questions
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  1. Independent Reading Book (IRB)As a reminder all students should be reading a non-fiction, grade/Lexile level book at least 20-25
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  2. Independent Reading Book (IRB)As a reminder all students should be reading a non-fiction, grade/Lexile level book at least 20-25
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  3. geneticscan you give me Write a 4-5 paragraph informational analysis essay on your IRB (Independent Reading Book). It has to be
    1. answers icon 1 answer
more similar questions