Question
make it sound like a 9th grader not too formal and keep it short not long
How does the dispute in the South China Sea demonstrate the need for boundaries between states?
How does the dispute in the South China Sea demonstrate the need for boundaries between states?
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
The dispute in the South China Sea shows why countries need clear boundaries. Lots of nations, like China, the Philippines, and Vietnam, want control over the same areas, mainly for resources like fish and oil. When there are no clear borders, it leads to conflicts and tensions. Setting boundaries can help avoid fights and keep peace, which is super important for countries that are so close to each other.
Answer
make it sound like a 9th grader not too formal and keep it short not long
China's claim on the South China Sea is considered a violation of UNCLOS because of several reasons:
1. Excessive Claims: China's "nine-dash line" covers a huge area that extends beyond what UNCLOS allows, which is usually a 200-mile Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) from a country's coastline.
2. Lack of Legal Basis: Other countries have established claims based on UNCLOS that conflict with China's claims, making China's position legally weak.
3. Ignoring Rights of Others: UNCLOS protects the rights of other nations to access resources and navigate in these waters, but China’s claims restrict those activities for other countries.
These issues create tensions and disputes in the region.
China's claim on the South China Sea is considered a violation of UNCLOS because of several reasons:
1. Excessive Claims: China's "nine-dash line" covers a huge area that extends beyond what UNCLOS allows, which is usually a 200-mile Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) from a country's coastline.
2. Lack of Legal Basis: Other countries have established claims based on UNCLOS that conflict with China's claims, making China's position legally weak.
3. Ignoring Rights of Others: UNCLOS protects the rights of other nations to access resources and navigate in these waters, but China’s claims restrict those activities for other countries.
These issues create tensions and disputes in the region.
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
China's claims in the South China Sea break the rules of UNCLOS for a few reasons:
1. **Too Much Area**: China's "nine-dash line" covers way more water than UNCLOS allows, which is usually just 200 miles from a country's coast.
2. **Weak Legal Standing**: Other countries have their claims based on UNCLOS that clash with China’s, so their legal argument isn’t strong.
3. **Ignoring Others' Rights**: UNCLOS gives everyone the right to access and use resources in these waters, but China’s claims block that for other countries.
All these points lead to a lot of tension and conflict in the area.
1. **Too Much Area**: China's "nine-dash line" covers way more water than UNCLOS allows, which is usually just 200 miles from a country's coast.
2. **Weak Legal Standing**: Other countries have their claims based on UNCLOS that clash with China’s, so their legal argument isn’t strong.
3. **Ignoring Others' Rights**: UNCLOS gives everyone the right to access and use resources in these waters, but China’s claims block that for other countries.
All these points lead to a lot of tension and conflict in the area.