Question
Carley wrote this note to her mother.
Dear Mom,
I just read online that people with pets live longer. Psychologists have proven that children with pets learn to be more responsible and empathetic. Dogs provide great home security and companionship. I think a puppy would be the perfect gift for my birthday, don’t you?
Love,
Carley
What is Carley's opinion, and how does she support it with evidence?
Carley's opinion is that people with pets live longer. She uses psychological facts to provide textual evidence.
Carley's opinion is that dogs provide great home security. She uses the fact that a puppy would be a great gift as evidence.
Carley's opinion is that dogs teach responsibility to kids. She uses an online article as textual evidence.
Carley's opinion is that a puppy would be a great birthday gift. She uses scientific evidence about children learning responsibility to support her opinion.
Dear Mom,
I just read online that people with pets live longer. Psychologists have proven that children with pets learn to be more responsible and empathetic. Dogs provide great home security and companionship. I think a puppy would be the perfect gift for my birthday, don’t you?
Love,
Carley
What is Carley's opinion, and how does she support it with evidence?
Carley's opinion is that people with pets live longer. She uses psychological facts to provide textual evidence.
Carley's opinion is that dogs provide great home security. She uses the fact that a puppy would be a great gift as evidence.
Carley's opinion is that dogs teach responsibility to kids. She uses an online article as textual evidence.
Carley's opinion is that a puppy would be a great birthday gift. She uses scientific evidence about children learning responsibility to support her opinion.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
Carley's opinion is that a puppy would be a great birthday gift. She supports this opinion with evidence by referencing scientific findings that show people with pets tend to live longer, that children with pets learn to be more responsible and empathetic, and that dogs provide companionship and home security.