The Australian Constitution serves as the foundational legal document delineating the structure, powers, and functions of the Australian government. It plays a critical role in protecting human rights, both express and implied, though it is not a dedicated human rights charter like those found in other countries, such as the U.S. Bill of Rights or the European Convention on Human Rights.
Express Human Rights
The Australian Constitution includes certain express rights, which are explicitly stated within the text. These rights are limited in scope compared to other international human rights frameworks. The key express rights in the Constitution include:
- Section 41: Provides that no person who has a right to vote at federal elections shall be disqualified from voting at state elections.
- Section 51(xxxi): Ensures that the Commonwealth cannot acquire property without just compensation.
- Section 80: Guarantees the right to a jury trial for indictable offenses.
- Section 116: Prevents the Commonwealth from making laws establishing religion or prohibiting the free exercise of religion.
- Section 117: Prohibits discrimination on the basis of state residency.
These express rights offer some protection against legislative and governmental abuses, but they are limited in number and scope.
Implied Human Rights
In addition to express rights, the High Court of Australia has recognized that certain human rights are implied within the Constitution through its interpretation. This concept was established in cases such as:
-
Theophanous v Herald & Weekly Times Ltd (1994) and McGinty v Western Australia (1996): The High Court inferred an implied right to political communication, grounded in the need for a functioning democracy and free expression of political views.
-
Rowe v Electoral Commissioner (2010): The Court highlighted that the Constitution guarantees a system of representative democracy, which extends to the right of the people to participate in free and fair elections.
Such implied rights are not explicitly mentioned in the Constitution but are deemed essential for the effective operation of democratic governance and the functioning of the legal system.
Foreign Affairs Power (Section 51)
Section 51 of the Constitution grants the Commonwealth Parliament the power to make laws with respect to various matters, one of which is "foreign affairs." The foreign affairs power gives the federal government the authority to engage in international treaties and conventions, including those related to human rights.
-
Implementation of International Treaties: The foreign affairs power can be used to implement and enforce international human rights treaties Australia has ratified, such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). This engenders a pathway for the incorporation of international human rights norms into domestic law.
-
Courts' Interpretation: Australian courts may rely on international human rights standards when interpreting existing laws and constitutional principles. This can strengthen the protection of human rights further and align domestic law with international obligations.
-
Limitations: It is important to note that the foreign affairs power does not automatically incorporate international law into domestic law. The Australian Parliament must enact specific legislation to give effect to international treaties, which can sometimes be politically contentious.
Conclusion
While the Australian Constitution provides a framework for the protection of human rights, the express rights are limited and heavily reliant on legislative action for broader protections. The implied rights recognized by the High Court reflect evolving social values and are crucial for safeguarding democratic principles. Meanwhile, Section 51's foreign affairs power serves as an avenue for integrating international human rights norms within the Australian legal system, albeit contingent on government action. Therefore, while the Australian Constitution provides some protection for human rights, it may not be as comprehensive as constitutions that explicitly include a bill of rights, necessitating ongoing dialogue and reform in the Australian context.
1 answer