Question
Your friend runs into your room and shows you the latest TikTok video. Plant-e-man (@plant.e.man) explains how you can save money and the environment by stopping eating food altogether! He has discovered a way for humans to create their own food by photosynthesis! He calls it the "make it or die" challenge. As you keep watching the video you see the ending where Plant-e-man says "It takes about 2 months to kickstart your body and those suck! But I've been doing this for 6 months and feel better than I have ever felt before!" Your friend is so excited!
Write the conversation you will have with your friend. Make sure to not just talk about but explain reliable resources including the words "peer reviewed" and "validity".
Write the conversation you will have with your friend. Make sure to not just talk about but explain reliable resources including the words "peer reviewed" and "validity".
Answers
GPT-4o mini
**You:** Wow, that TikTok video is really something! But I have to say, I’m a bit skeptical about this whole photosynthesis idea. It sounds pretty wild.
**Friend:** But Plant-e-man looked so healthy! He said he’s been doing it for six months! Why would he lie?
**You:** I get that. But just because someone looks healthy or claims to feel better doesn’t necessarily mean what they’re doing is safe or effective. We should really look for peer-reviewed studies on this topic. Peer-reviewed articles are evaluated by other experts in the field before being published, which helps ensure their reliability.
**Friend:** So what’s the deal with photosynthesis for humans? Isn’t it a normal process for plants?
**You:** Exactly! Plants have chlorophyll that allows them to convert sunlight into energy, which humans obviously don’t have. Our bodies don’t possess the necessary biological machinery to perform photosynthesis. If something like that were possible, there would be valid scientific evidence to support it—something published in medical or nutritional journals that go through that rigorous peer-review process.
**Friend:** But Plant-e-man said he feels great! Couldn’t it work for some people?
**You:** Personal anecdotes can be compelling, but they don't provide the full picture. Just because someone claims to feel better doesn’t guarantee that what they’re doing is healthy. The validity of his claims requires more than just his experience; we need to see scientific proof that supports such radical changes in human diet. The absence of peer-reviewed studies on “making food” via photosynthesis for humans is pretty telling.
**Friend:** What should I tell him when I see him next?
**You:** I’d recommend sharing your concerns. Tell him it’s okay to be excited about new ideas, but we need reliable information to make safe choices. Suggest looking into credible nutrition sources where experts can provide evidence about what our bodies truly need for health.
**Friend:** That makes sense! I want to be excited, but also smart about this.
**You:** Exactly! It’s all about finding that balance. There's a lot of misinformation out there, especially on social media. Prioritizing reliable, scientifically-backed info will help keep both of you safe and informed!
**Friend:** But Plant-e-man looked so healthy! He said he’s been doing it for six months! Why would he lie?
**You:** I get that. But just because someone looks healthy or claims to feel better doesn’t necessarily mean what they’re doing is safe or effective. We should really look for peer-reviewed studies on this topic. Peer-reviewed articles are evaluated by other experts in the field before being published, which helps ensure their reliability.
**Friend:** So what’s the deal with photosynthesis for humans? Isn’t it a normal process for plants?
**You:** Exactly! Plants have chlorophyll that allows them to convert sunlight into energy, which humans obviously don’t have. Our bodies don’t possess the necessary biological machinery to perform photosynthesis. If something like that were possible, there would be valid scientific evidence to support it—something published in medical or nutritional journals that go through that rigorous peer-review process.
**Friend:** But Plant-e-man said he feels great! Couldn’t it work for some people?
**You:** Personal anecdotes can be compelling, but they don't provide the full picture. Just because someone claims to feel better doesn’t guarantee that what they’re doing is healthy. The validity of his claims requires more than just his experience; we need to see scientific proof that supports such radical changes in human diet. The absence of peer-reviewed studies on “making food” via photosynthesis for humans is pretty telling.
**Friend:** What should I tell him when I see him next?
**You:** I’d recommend sharing your concerns. Tell him it’s okay to be excited about new ideas, but we need reliable information to make safe choices. Suggest looking into credible nutrition sources where experts can provide evidence about what our bodies truly need for health.
**Friend:** That makes sense! I want to be excited, but also smart about this.
**You:** Exactly! It’s all about finding that balance. There's a lot of misinformation out there, especially on social media. Prioritizing reliable, scientifically-backed info will help keep both of you safe and informed!