To gather evidence to support an inference about whether the bacteria in the Petri dish had developed from the material left from the earlier experiment, the best approach would be:
A. Take a sample of the bacteria and grow it in an incubator.
By culturing the bacteria in a controlled environment, the scientist can analyze its growth characteristics, morphology, and possibly perform genetic sequencing to determine its identity. This would help establish whether the bacteria are indeed related to or derived from the material used in the earlier experiment.
While trying the original experiment again with uncleaned dishes (Option D) could also provide insights, it is not as direct as the initial step of culturing the bacteria found. Gathering dirty Petri dishes from other labs (Option B) and checking clean dishes for residue (Option C) would not provide conclusive evidence regarding the specific bacteria in question.