Question
Statement 1: For many new immigrants, arriving at Ellis Island was a hopeful but anxious experience.
Statement 2: Ellis Island is a place rich with history that everyone should visit at least once.
Why is the first statement a better example of a thesis statement than the second statement?
(1 point)
Responses
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement includes a transition.
Statement 2: Ellis Island is a place rich with history that everyone should visit at least once.
Why is the first statement a better example of a thesis statement than the second statement?
(1 point)
Responses
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement avoids opinions.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement summarizes a central idea.
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement uses description to draw readers in.
The first statement includes a transition.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
The correct response is: **The first statement summarizes a central idea.**
This is because the first statement presents a clear, focused concept about the experiences of new immigrants at Ellis Island, which can be further explored and supported in an essay or discussion. In contrast, the second statement expresses a subjective opinion about visiting Ellis Island, which may not serve as a strong thesis for deeper analysis.
This is because the first statement presents a clear, focused concept about the experiences of new immigrants at Ellis Island, which can be further explored and supported in an essay or discussion. In contrast, the second statement expresses a subjective opinion about visiting Ellis Island, which may not serve as a strong thesis for deeper analysis.