Question

After reading the novel please answer the following questions: What do you think of Janie’s choices for husbands, who are you most like of the three in terms of your goals in life? You can see how the novel addresses the problem of social convention and respectability, how people should balance the need for social status, financial security, and personal desires. Are you like Janie in how you look at the world? Answer these two questions as best you can, reflecting on your own goals and self image, what you think is important in a life. The answer should be between 250-500 words in length, and use examples from your choice of UA as a school, classes, what your parents or guardians except from you, the sense of social pressure you experience now in your own life to provide an interesting perspective on the novel.

Answer 1

In Zora Neale Hurston's "Their Eyes Were Watching God," Janie's choices for husbands reflect her evolving understanding of love, independence, and self-fulfillment. Each relationship she enters—first with Logan Killicks, then with Joe Starks, and finally with Teacake—reveals different facets of her desires and societal pressures, ultimately contributing to her self-discovery. Janie's journey resonates deeply with me, as I navigate the delicate balance between societal expectations and pursuing my personal goals and desires.

Initially, Janie's marriage to Logan Killicks symbolizes a partnership built on practicality rather than passion. This choice echoes societal norms that prioritize financial security over personal happiness. In my own life, I feel the weight of similar expectations from my family and community—an underlying belief that success is linked to traditional constructs of achievement, such as stable employment or financial independence. However, like Janie, I yearn for fulfillment beyond these superficial markers. I’ve chosen my major at UA to reflect my passion for social justice, which may diverge from the conventional paths laid out for me. While my parents have high hopes for me—primarily focused on achieving financial success—I find myself drawn to engaging in meaningful work that reflects my values and beliefs.

Janie's second marriage to Joe Starks further complicates her understanding of respectability, as she sacrifices her voice and individuality in exchange for a certain social status. Similarly, I experience social pressure to conform to peer expectations, particularly regarding career aspirations and social popularity. The weight of these conventions can be stifling, much like how Janie feels trapped by Joe’s controlling nature. My involvement in various student organizations at UA has taught me the importance of aligning with supportive communities that nurture my values rather than conforming to external pressures. I try to seek out spaces where I can be authentic and continue to grow, parallel to Janie’s eventual rebellion against Joe’s dominance.

In her final relationship with Teacake, Janie embraces the idea of a partnership based on mutual respect and love. This deeply resonates with me as I strive to surround myself with relationships that uplift rather than diminish. Teacake introduces a playfulness and appreciation for life's fleeting moments, which inspires me to pursue experiences and connections that bring joy. I, too, value enriching relationships and experiences over the hollow pursuit of prestige.

Ultimately, Janie's journey emphasizes the importance of self-identity beyond societal expectations. Despite the pressures I face today at UA, I aim to carve a path aligned with my passions and values while nurturing relationships that reflect my true self. As I reflect on Janie’s evolution and my own goals, I realize that fulfillment lies in authenticity, contributing positively to my community, and finding joy in meaningful connections—principles I hold dear as I navigate my own journey.