Question
imagine that you are given two milky white crystals, each with 2 cm across.you are told the that one of the crystal is composed of plagioclase and other of quartz.how can you determine which is which?
Answers
There are no human answers yet.
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
To distinguish between plagioclase and quartz, you can use several methods based on their physical properties. Here are some techniques:
1. **Hardness Test**: The Mohs scale of mineral hardness can be helpful. Quartz has a hardness of about 7, while plagioclase has a hardness of about 6-6.5. You can perform a scratch test using a metal object or another mineral. If the crystal can scratch the object, it is likely quartz. If the object can scratch the crystal, it may be plagioclase.
2. **Cleavage vs. Fracture**: Plagioclase has distinct cleavage and will break along planes, while quartz has a conchoidal fracture with no cleavage. Examine the surfaces of the crystals. If you see flat, shiny surfaces, you’re likely looking at plagioclase; if the surfaces are smooth and curve, it's likely quartz.
3. **Luster**: While both minerals can have a vitreous luster, plagioclase may show a more pearly or dull appearance, especially if weathered. Compare the luster of both crystals under a light source.
4. **Transparency and Color**: Both crystals can be colorless and transparent, but plagioclase crystals may show a slight opalescence or a white, cloudy appearance due to the presence of fine inclusions. Examine the clarity and color closely.
5. **Twining**: Some plagioclase crystals exhibit twinning, particularly if you look at them under a polarized light microscope. If you're in a lab setting, you could use a simple polarized light test to see if you can identify the characteristic twinning of plagioclase.
6. **Acid Test**: Quartz does not react to hydrochloric acid, while some plagioclase may show a slight reaction, especially if it contains small amounts of other minerals. However, this is a less common method for distinguishing these two minerals.
Combining observations from these methods will give you a strong indication of which crystal is quartz and which is plagioclase. Always take care when handling the crystals and perform any tests safely.
1. **Hardness Test**: The Mohs scale of mineral hardness can be helpful. Quartz has a hardness of about 7, while plagioclase has a hardness of about 6-6.5. You can perform a scratch test using a metal object or another mineral. If the crystal can scratch the object, it is likely quartz. If the object can scratch the crystal, it may be plagioclase.
2. **Cleavage vs. Fracture**: Plagioclase has distinct cleavage and will break along planes, while quartz has a conchoidal fracture with no cleavage. Examine the surfaces of the crystals. If you see flat, shiny surfaces, you’re likely looking at plagioclase; if the surfaces are smooth and curve, it's likely quartz.
3. **Luster**: While both minerals can have a vitreous luster, plagioclase may show a more pearly or dull appearance, especially if weathered. Compare the luster of both crystals under a light source.
4. **Transparency and Color**: Both crystals can be colorless and transparent, but plagioclase crystals may show a slight opalescence or a white, cloudy appearance due to the presence of fine inclusions. Examine the clarity and color closely.
5. **Twining**: Some plagioclase crystals exhibit twinning, particularly if you look at them under a polarized light microscope. If you're in a lab setting, you could use a simple polarized light test to see if you can identify the characteristic twinning of plagioclase.
6. **Acid Test**: Quartz does not react to hydrochloric acid, while some plagioclase may show a slight reaction, especially if it contains small amounts of other minerals. However, this is a less common method for distinguishing these two minerals.
Combining observations from these methods will give you a strong indication of which crystal is quartz and which is plagioclase. Always take care when handling the crystals and perform any tests safely.
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.