Question
Write a Creative Letter to President Truman, trying to convince him of your claim/thesis.
^ My claim is : The decision to use the atomic bomb against Japan in World War II was unjustified, as evidence suggests, Japan was already on the brink of surrendering. ^
Include your one-sentence thesis statement, reasons, evidence, and how to challenge the counter-argument from your chart. Below are my reasons and evidence, I just need to help putting it together in paragraphs. We are only allowed to write 2 paragraphs.
Reason 1: The Japanese were ready to surrender and they were already defeated. Info from Document #2
Reason 2: The loss of many people's lives, since there is no way to protect people from nuclear weapons. Info from Document #4
Reason 3: The consequences of the bombing impacted the environment detrimentally. Info from Document #8
Counter-Argument: The US was completely justified in using the atomic bomb against
Japan in WWII. Info found in Document #6.
My response to the counter argument: In document 7, toward the end of President Truman's press release he stated "we have used it to shorten the agony of war, in order to save the lives of thousands and thousands of young Americans." So President Truman's goal was to save lives, but in order to do that he was completely ok with dropping a bomb that killed 200,000 or more helpless civilians.
^ My claim is : The decision to use the atomic bomb against Japan in World War II was unjustified, as evidence suggests, Japan was already on the brink of surrendering. ^
Include your one-sentence thesis statement, reasons, evidence, and how to challenge the counter-argument from your chart. Below are my reasons and evidence, I just need to help putting it together in paragraphs. We are only allowed to write 2 paragraphs.
Reason 1: The Japanese were ready to surrender and they were already defeated. Info from Document #2
Reason 2: The loss of many people's lives, since there is no way to protect people from nuclear weapons. Info from Document #4
Reason 3: The consequences of the bombing impacted the environment detrimentally. Info from Document #8
Counter-Argument: The US was completely justified in using the atomic bomb against
Japan in WWII. Info found in Document #6.
My response to the counter argument: In document 7, toward the end of President Truman's press release he stated "we have used it to shorten the agony of war, in order to save the lives of thousands and thousands of young Americans." So President Truman's goal was to save lives, but in order to do that he was completely ok with dropping a bomb that killed 200,000 or more helpless civilians.
Answers
Answered by
GPT 3.5
Dear President Truman,
I am writing to express my deep concerns regarding the decision to use the atomic bomb against Japan in World War II. As evidence suggests, Japan was already on the brink of surrendering before the bomb was dropped. The Japanese were ready to surrender and they were already defeated, as documented in various sources. The unnecessary loss of so many lives, including innocent civilians, is a tragedy that cannot be ignored. The devastation caused by nuclear weapons is unfathomable, and the consequences of the bombing have had a long-lasting impact on both the people and the environment.
Furthermore, the counter-argument that the US was justified in using the atomic bomb against Japan is flawed. While it may be argued that the bomb was used to save American lives, it cannot be denied that the decision resulted in the deaths of countless innocent civilians. Your own statement in a press release acknowledges the goal of saving lives, yet the means by which it was done raises serious ethical concerns. The decision to use the atomic bomb was not only unnecessary but also unjustified, as Japan was already on the verge of surrendering. I urge you to reconsider the implications of this decision and take responsibility for the devastating effects it has had on humanity.
Sincerely, [Your Name]
I am writing to express my deep concerns regarding the decision to use the atomic bomb against Japan in World War II. As evidence suggests, Japan was already on the brink of surrendering before the bomb was dropped. The Japanese were ready to surrender and they were already defeated, as documented in various sources. The unnecessary loss of so many lives, including innocent civilians, is a tragedy that cannot be ignored. The devastation caused by nuclear weapons is unfathomable, and the consequences of the bombing have had a long-lasting impact on both the people and the environment.
Furthermore, the counter-argument that the US was justified in using the atomic bomb against Japan is flawed. While it may be argued that the bomb was used to save American lives, it cannot be denied that the decision resulted in the deaths of countless innocent civilians. Your own statement in a press release acknowledges the goal of saving lives, yet the means by which it was done raises serious ethical concerns. The decision to use the atomic bomb was not only unnecessary but also unjustified, as Japan was already on the verge of surrendering. I urge you to reconsider the implications of this decision and take responsibility for the devastating effects it has had on humanity.
Sincerely, [Your Name]