Question

What was the Roman empire's views on Christianity at various points in its history? What caused them to change over time?

1 answer

The Roman Empire's views on Christianity varied significantly throughout its history. Here is an overview of the Empire's shifting attitudes towards Christianity and the factors that led to these changes:

1. Early Persecutions: In the early days of the Roman Empire (1st century AD), Christianity was considered a small, fringe sect. Initially, the Roman authorities generally ignored or dismissed Christians. However, as the Christian community grew and began to challenge the Roman pagan beliefs and practices, sporadic persecutions occurred. Most notably, Emperor Nero blamed Christians for the Great Fire of Rome in 64 AD and initiated a brutal crackdown on them, marking one of the earliest known persecutions.

2. Periods of Tolerance: From the 2nd to the mid-3rd centuries AD, several emperors adopted a more tolerant stance towards Christianity. For instance, Emperor Trajan (2nd century) instructed governors not to actively seek out Christians and only punish them if they refused to denounce their faith. This policy generally prevailed until the influence of Christianity grew even further.

3. Decius and Valerian Persecutions: In the mid-3rd century AD, Emperor Decius initiated some of the first organized and empire-wide persecutions of Christians. Decius saw Christians as a challenge to the authority and unity of the Empire, demanding absolute loyalty to the state. Emperor Valerian later intensified these persecutions, considering Christians as enemies of the Roman state.

4. Constantine's Conversion: The most significant turning point in the Roman Empire's view of Christianity came with the conversion of Emperor Constantine in the early 4th century AD. In 313 AD, Constantine issued the Edict of Milan, officially tolerating Christianity and putting an end to the persecutions. He later became a patron of the Christian Church, favoring it over other religions. This monumental change was largely influenced by Constantine's political ambitions, a desire for unity, and a strategic alliance with the growing Christian community.

5. Official Religion: By the end of the 4th century AD, Christianity, particularly in its Nicene Trinitarian form, became the favored and eventually the official religion of the Roman Empire. Emperor Theodosius I made Nicene Christianity the state religion in 380 AD, leading to the subsequent suppression of other religious practices, including paganism.

The changing views on Christianity over time were driven by a combination of socio-political factors, including the growing influence of Christianity, Christian resistance to assimilation, political ambitions of emperors, and their desire for social cohesion. Additionally, Christian teachings often ran counter to the traditional pagan beliefs, which led to tension and conflict between the two faiths. The ultimately victorious rise of Christianity was also influenced by internal divisions within the Roman Empire, as well as the support it gained from influential figures within the imperial court.