The student's claim that viruses are alive because they have genetic material and can reproduce is partially correct. Viruses do have genetic material (either DNA or RNA) and can replicate inside a host cell. However, they lack many other essential characteristics of living organisms.
Viruses themselves are not cells; they are acellular particles. They are completely dependent on host cells to carry out their replication and metabolism. Viruses do not exhibit growth, respiration, or independent movement like living organisms do. Additionally, viruses lack cellular organelles such as mitochondria or a nucleus.
While viruses can replicate, they cannot reproduce on their own as they lack the machinery to carry out their replication. Instead, they rely on infecting host cells and hijacking their cellular machinery to replicate themselves.
Therefore, according to the generally accepted criteria for life, viruses are not considered living organisms. They are often described as biological entities or infectious agents that bridge the gap between living and non-living things.
A student claims that viruses are alive because they have genetic material and can reproduce.is this students claim correct
1 answer