Question

As punishment, Romeo is banished from Verona. Is this punishment fair?
Claim #2- (One reason that supports your general claim/thesis)

Answer 1

No, the punishment of banishment is not fair because Romeo did not commit a crime worthy of such a severe punishment.

Evidence to support claim #2:

Firstly, the reason for Romeo's banishment was due to his involvement in a fight with Tybalt, which resulted in Tybalt's death. However, Romeo only acted out of self-defense as Tybalt was the one who initiated the fight. In this case, Romeo's actions were justified, and it is unfair to punish him for defending himself.

Furthermore, the punishment of banishment is too severe for the crime committed. Although fighting and causing harm to another person is wrong, banishing Romeo from his home, family, and friends is an extreme punishment. It not only causes Romeo emotional distress, but it also separates him from his wife, who he only just married.

Overall, the punishment of banishing Romeo from Verona is not fair, as his actions were justified, and the punishment is too severe for the crime committed.