Asked by Arushi
I3- Oxidation number
Answers
Answered by
Arushi
-1
Answered by
DrBob222
I don't agree with this answer but as I look on the web I find that most answers do agree with your answer.
By rule, and after all oxidation numbers are just a set of made up rules, the oxidation number (ON) of a mono-atomic ion is the charge on an ion. Therefore, the ON of I^- is -1. By rules the SUM of the oxidation states of a polyatomic ion is equals the charge on the ion. Therefrore, the charge on the [I^3]^- is -1/3 + -1/3 + -1/3 = -1 so EACH ion has an ON of -1/3. Yes, I know that [I3]^- is made up of I2 (zero ON) + I^- to make I3^- and many of the answers I see on the web wax eloquently about the bonding electrons and they give zero ON to the I2 and -1 ON to the lone I^- and follow then with [I3]^- being -1. That's baloney in my opinion. BY RULE, the ON of each I is -1/3. The CHARGE in the [I3]^- is -1 but the ON is -1/3 for each. Likewise, the charge on the I in KI is -1 but the ON of IODINE (NOT IODIDE ION) IS -1
By rule, and after all oxidation numbers are just a set of made up rules, the oxidation number (ON) of a mono-atomic ion is the charge on an ion. Therefore, the ON of I^- is -1. By rules the SUM of the oxidation states of a polyatomic ion is equals the charge on the ion. Therefrore, the charge on the [I^3]^- is -1/3 + -1/3 + -1/3 = -1 so EACH ion has an ON of -1/3. Yes, I know that [I3]^- is made up of I2 (zero ON) + I^- to make I3^- and many of the answers I see on the web wax eloquently about the bonding electrons and they give zero ON to the I2 and -1 ON to the lone I^- and follow then with [I3]^- being -1. That's baloney in my opinion. BY RULE, the ON of each I is -1/3. The CHARGE in the [I3]^- is -1 but the ON is -1/3 for each. Likewise, the charge on the I in KI is -1 but the ON of IODINE (NOT IODIDE ION) IS -1
There are no AI answers yet. The ability to request AI answers is coming soon!
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.