Asked by rfvv
He recorded his life there in his diary.
=> He recorded his life in Antarctica in his diary.
1. Which life did he record in his diary?
2. Which life of his did he record in his diary?
- He recorded his life in Antarctica in his diary.
[Which question is suitable for the answer?]
3. Where did he record his life in his diary?
- He recorded his life in his diary / in Antarctica. [3-1]
- He recorded his life in Antarctica in his diary. [3-2]
[If somebody asks this question, can we answer as in the above? In this case, is 'in Antarctica' an adverbial phrase? Can we use [3-2] as a suitable answer?]
=> He recorded his life in Antarctica in his diary.
1. Which life did he record in his diary?
2. Which life of his did he record in his diary?
- He recorded his life in Antarctica in his diary.
[Which question is suitable for the answer?]
3. Where did he record his life in his diary?
- He recorded his life in his diary / in Antarctica. [3-1]
- He recorded his life in Antarctica in his diary. [3-2]
[If somebody asks this question, can we answer as in the above? In this case, is 'in Antarctica' an adverbial phrase? Can we use [3-2] as a suitable answer?]
Answers
Answered by
Writeacher
In all these sentences, "in Antarctica" is an adjective modifying "life."
Since we all have only one life, I wouldn't use either 1 or 2. I'd ask, "What part of his life did he record in his diary?"
If you want "in Antarctica" to be used as an adverb, then here's how:
~ In Antarctica, he recorded his life in his diary.
Remember, as I've written before -- the adjective or adverb needs to be as close to what it's modifying as possible to be crystal clear.
Since we all have only one life, I wouldn't use either 1 or 2. I'd ask, "What part of his life did he record in his diary?"
If you want "in Antarctica" to be used as an adverb, then here's how:
~ In Antarctica, he recorded his life in his diary.
Remember, as I've written before -- the adjective or adverb needs to be as close to what it's modifying as possible to be crystal clear.
There are no AI answers yet. The ability to request AI answers is coming soon!
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.