Asked by rfvv
posted by rfvv Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 8:44am.
---------------------------------------What does 1)it refer to?
Does 1) it refer to 'the musical pipe'? Or is 1) it "Situation It"?
Good! Now, hold the musical pipe and blow across each straw.
- 1)It's cool. How does 2)it make a sound?
What does 2)it refer to?
Does 2) it refer to 'the musical pipe' or 'each straw'?
•
English - Writeacher Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 9:33am
1) In "It's cool!" it refers to the experience in general.
2) "It" refers to the musical pipe.
•
English - Reed Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 9:34am
It refers to the instrument, the pipe.
•
English - Reed Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 9:37am
Yes, in 1) it could refer to either the experience or the pipe itself.
===================================
Good! Now, hold the musical pipe and blow across each straw.
- 1)It's cool. How does 2)it make a sound?
[Doesn't '2)it' refer to 'each straw'?]
---------------------------------------What does 1)it refer to?
Does 1) it refer to 'the musical pipe'? Or is 1) it "Situation It"?
Good! Now, hold the musical pipe and blow across each straw.
- 1)It's cool. How does 2)it make a sound?
What does 2)it refer to?
Does 2) it refer to 'the musical pipe' or 'each straw'?
•
English - Writeacher Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 9:33am
1) In "It's cool!" it refers to the experience in general.
2) "It" refers to the musical pipe.
•
English - Reed Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 9:34am
It refers to the instrument, the pipe.
•
English - Reed Wednesday, October 25, 2017 at 9:37am
Yes, in 1) it could refer to either the experience or the pipe itself.
===================================
Good! Now, hold the musical pipe and blow across each straw.
- 1)It's cool. How does 2)it make a sound?
[Doesn't '2)it' refer to 'each straw'?]
Answers
Answered by
Writeacher
I wouldn't take it that way. It takes multiple straws to make a pipe, and it's the whole pipe that makes the sound(s). That's why I take "it" to refer to the whole pipe, not each straw individually.