Which sentence is correct?

Question

A. John took Anna and them to the park.
B. John took Anna and I to the park.
C. John took Anna and he to the park.
D. John took Anna her to the park.

Can't decide between B and C?

Answer 1

Remove "Anna and" and then read each sentence aloud.

Let us know.

Answer 2

John took he to the park. <~~????

Answer 3

B doesn't seem correct either, and A and D are not really different (to me).

Answer 4

D makes no sense at all.

What happens with A when you remove "Anna and"?

Answer 5

D was supposed to be "Anna and her..."

Answer 6

So ... I see two correct answers here then: A and D. Both are grammatically correct.

Answer 7

D. is missing a word.

Answer 8

Thanks!